Custom Cake Info.
At Patty's Cakes, we're all about flavor! Our cakes are topped and filled with a light, airy icing that strikes the perfect balance between taste and texture, without being too sugary or hard.
We love creating Custom Cakes for any occasion and taste buds. With 11 cake flavors and 22 fillings to choose from, we're sure to make your dessert unforgettable.
Custom Cakes are the perfect way to tailor your cake to your event. You can mix and match flavors, select colors, get creative with the design, and feed any crowd size. We also offer gluten-free and vegan options.
Please keep in mind that we require advance ordering to give your Custom Cake the time and attention it deserves. So plan ahead and let us create a delicious cake for your next celebration, whether it's a birthday, baby shower, bridal shower, religious event, or anything in between!
Cake Pricing
Buy Online and Save up to 41%!
Select, customize, and checkout with your cake online and save!
Custom Cake Sizes and Shapes
Round Cakes
| Size/Shape | Serves | Starting Regular Price: (?) |
Starting Online Price: (?) |
Savings | Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4" Round Smash Cake (no filling) | Serves: 1 | Starting Regular Price: $33 | Starting Online Price: $25 | Savings: 32% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 8" Round Single Layer | Serves: 11 | Starting Regular Price: $69 | Starting Online Price: $49 | Savings: 41% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 10" Round Single Layer | Serves: 16 | Starting Regular Price: $79 | Starting Online Price: $59 | Savings: 34% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 6" Round Double Layer | Serves: 12 | Starting Regular Price: $73 | Starting Online Price: $53 | Savings: 38% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 8" Round Double Layer | Serves: 23 | Starting Regular Price: $85 | Starting Online Price: $65 | Savings: 31% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 10" Round Double Layer | Serves: 36 | Starting Regular Price: $109 | Starting Online Price: $89 | Savings: 22% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
Sheet Cakes
| Size/Shape | Serves | Starting Regular Price: (?) |
Starting Online Price: (?) |
Savings | Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8x11 Sheet | Serves: 20 | Starting Regular Price: $85 | Starting Online Price: $65 | Savings: 31% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| Quarter Sheet | Serves: 29 | Starting Regular Price: $95 | Starting Online Price: $75 | Savings: 27% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| Third Sheet | Serves: 37 | Starting Regular Price: $107 | Starting Online Price: $87 | Savings: 23% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| Half Sheet | Serves: 48 | Starting Regular Price: $119 | Starting Online Price: $99 | Savings: 20% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| Two-Thirds Sheet | Serves: 75 | Starting Regular Price: $155 | Starting Online Price: $135 | Savings: 15% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| Full Sheet | Serves: 100 | Starting Regular Price: $191 | Starting Online Price: $171 | Savings: 12% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
Heart Cake
| Size/Shape | Serves | Starting Regular Price: (?) |
Starting Online Price: (?) |
Savings | Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8" Round Double Layer | Serves: 23 | Starting Regular Price: $109 | Starting Online Price: $95 | Savings: 15% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
Tiered Cakes
| Size/Shape | Serves | Starting Regular Price: (?) |
Starting Online Price: (?) |
Savings | Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Tier Round (5" & 8") | Serves: 30 | Starting Regular Price: $199 | Starting Online Price: $169 | Savings: 15% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 2 Tier Round (6" & 9") | Serves: 40 | Starting Regular Price: $209 | Starting Online Price: $179 | Savings: 14% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 2 Tier Round (6" & 10") | Serves: 47 | Starting Regular Price: $229 | Starting Online Price: $199 | Savings: 13% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 2 Tier Round (6" & 11") | Serves: 55 | Starting Regular Price: $259 | Starting Online Price: $229 | Savings: 12% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 2 Tier Round (6" & 12") | Serves: 65 | Starting Regular Price: $279 | Starting Online Price: $249 | Savings: 11% - Buy online and save! (?) |
order online |
| 3-4-5 Tier Round and Square Cakes | Serves: 75-500+ | Starting Regular Price: $375+ | - | - | request |
Cake Pricing Explained
Starting Online Price
This pricing is available for cakes purchased on our online store only. This is the starting price, plus artwork. The pricing will be listed on each cake.
Starting Regular Price
Is the pricing used when placing your order via email or in-person. This is the starting price, plus artwork.
What if your design is not available online?
Then the cake will be priced at the "Regular Starting Price." Yes, even if your design is only slightly different.
What is included?
All cakes include a filling and a basic design for the price listed. Additional artwork or changes will increase the price.
Sales tax is not collected.
Need More?
Not seeing what you are looking for? Send us a message
Custom Cakes Explained
New to cake lingo? We are here to help. Let's get visual.
The dotted pink line is the filling
Custom Cake Icing
We ice our cakes in a light, airy icing, instead of hard fondant or overly sugary buttercream. Our light icing provides the perfect balance for flavor and texture as a topper and filling to our cakes.
Need help choosing a flavor combination?
Get fancy with our cake flavor chart.
Classic Cake Flavors
Classic Cake Fillings
Fillings
Fruit FillingsSimilar to a jam. Pairs well with vanilla bavarian custard or cream cheese mousse.
Popular Flavors
Items marked with this symbol are popular flavors.
Custom Cake Design
Your greeting, your colors, and a basic design are included in the price of your cake. If you want to go for a real wow factor, we can always get more elaborate for an additional charge.
Check out our photo galleries if you need some inspiration on the design, or send us a message today. We're here to help you make something memorable.
View Cake PhotosCustom Cake Colors
Here is our selection colors available for cakes and cupcakes. Keep in mind, that this is food, so colors will look slightly different, and we cannot match colors. We highly recommend avoiding deeper colors because they will bleed (not run) into the surrounding icing.
Color Swatches
Super Red Regular
Pastel
Tourmaline Regular
Pastel
Neon Pink Regular
Pastel
Rose Pink Regular
Pastel
Sunset Orange Regular
Pastel
Golden Yellow Regular
Pastel
Lemon Yellow Regular
Pastel
Lime Green Regular
Pastel
Leaf Green Regular
Pastel
Olive Green Regular
Pastel
Teal Green Regular
Pastel
Sky Blue Regular
Pastel
Royal Blue Regular
Pastel
Navy Blue Regular
Pastel
Sapphire Regular
Pastel
Violet Regular
Pastel
Burgundy Wine Regular
Pastel
Brown Regular
Pastel
Stone Gray Regular
Pastel
Black Regular
Pastel
Ivory Regular
Classic Gold Regular
True Silver Regular
Edible Image
Have a photo or logo you'd like to feature on your cake? We can print it on edible icing!
| Edible Images | Price |
|---|---|
| 8x11 Print | $20 |
| 11x17 Print | $30 |
You may inquire about a cake with an edible image or submit an image for an already placed order.
How To Order Custom Cakes
Options
Order online to save up to 48%, send us a message, or schedule an appointment with a cake specialist and your order can be placed in minutes. It's easy as pie… or cake.
Order OnlineCake counter Hours
Tuesday-Friday, 10:00 am to 5:00 pm,
Saturday, 10:00 am to 4:00 pm
Appointment is required, schedule one now.
The Earlier the Better
We recommend placing your order as soon as you can, being early is a good thing. Our busiest days are Fridays and Saturdays and they always sell out, therefore we recommend placing your order 1-3 weeks ahead of time. We have many options of cakes to fit your timeframe or design requirements. We work within a first-come, first-served method and will accept new orders until we have reached capacity.
Cancellation/Change Policy
Organizing hundreds of weekly orders and ensuring quality takes a lot of prep time. Seven (7) days prior to the order date, all custom cake orders are final, the pickup time cannot be moved up, and no changes can be made to the items. If you must make a change, if available, there will be a $30 change fee added to the order.
